Birthright Citizenship Ruling
Four Supreme Court justices believe birthright citizenship can be repealed, though the court prevented Trump from fully recreating the American republic.
1The Bulwark Podcast
David French and Tim Miller analyze the Supreme Court's recent term, focusing on the birthright citizenship ruling and broader political implications.
The Supreme Court issued a ruling on birthright citizenship where four justices believed the fundamental law could be repealed, though the court stopped Trump from recreating the American republic.
1Prepared by GenPodAI-assisted and grounded in publisher-provided material
Four Supreme Court justices believe birthright citizenship can be repealed, though the court prevented Trump from fully recreating the American republic.
1While Trump achieved significant wins from the Supreme Court this term, he also suffered massive losses.
2The Department of Justice is mostly losing its immigration protest cases.
4Democrats need a bigger tent but must establish lines the party will not cross, according to the discussion.
4Ask GenPod next
“What specific arguments did the four justices use to support repealing birthright citizenship?”
“Which specific Supreme Court cases constituted Trump's massive losses this term?”
“What lines does David French believe the Democratic party should not cross?”
Questions
The Supreme Court stopped Trump from recreating the American republic, but four justices believe birthright citizenship can be repealed.
1Trump had some big wins but also had massive losses.
2The DOJ is mostly losing its immigration protest cases.
4Experts
Sources and disclosure
Primary material
GenPod used an AI-assisted workflow to organize publisher-provided show notes into a listening guide. It is not independent reporting or fact-checking; verify important claims against the source episode.
Read our methodologyReport a correctionThis guide is based on the episode 'David French: The Birthright Citizenship Ruling Should've Been 9-0' from The Bulwark Podcast, published on 2026-06-30.
GenPod publishes an independent listening guide. Rights in the original podcast audio, artwork, show notes, and trademarks belong to their respective owners.
If you own or represent the rights and believe material on this page is used without authorization, request review or removal. Include the original work, the material at issue, and your contact information.
SCOTUS did manage, for now, to stop Trump from recreating the American republic, but four of the court's justices believe that the fundamental law of birthright citizenship in the Constitution can just be repealed—along with the very nature of what American citizenship means.
But overall, while Trump had some big wins from the Supreme Court this term, he also had massive losses.
David runs down some of the latest rulings with Tim.
Plus: Mamdani doesn't think the Constitution should be changed so he can run for POTUS (David thinks he's wrong), Platner is not winning over white working-class voters, Dems need a bigger tent but there have to be lines the party won't cross, and the DOJ is (mostly) losing its immigration protest cases.
David French joins Tim Miller.
Show notes:
• David's Newsletter on one-party rule • David on the purging of Gen. Donahue • More on the Broadview case in Chicago, from David
This week only, a full Bulwark membership for everything we offer on our website is $86 a year. That's 14 percent off at http://thebulwark.com/july4
Related listening guides