Talking Dateline

Out of the Darkness: The Poynter Case

Andrea Canning and Josh Mankiewicz examine the fatal shooting of fire captain Bob Poynter and the subsequent investigation into his wife, Chacey.

The episode discusses the 2016 fatal shooting of Bob Poynter by a stranger on a Texas country road and the police investigation that questioned the genuineness of his wife Chacey's reaction.

13
25 minJul 8, 2026Dateline NBC

Prepared by GenPodAI-assisted and grounded in publisher-provided material

Listen to the original

Key takeaways

01

The Incident

In 2016, Chacey Poynter called 911 to report that her husband, Bob, a fire captain, had been fatally shot by a stranger on a Texas country road.

1
02

Police Findings

When police arrived, they found Chacey covered in her husband's blood, but investigators quickly surmised that her emotion and story were far from genuine.

23
03

Investigative Focus

The discussion covers the intensity of Chacey's reaction captured on police body cam and the role life insurance policies can play in murders.

4

Ask GenPod next

Keep the question moving.

01

“What other Dateline episodes feature life insurance motives?”

02

“How does police body cam footage influence public perception of suspects?”

03

“What is the full story of the 'Out of the Darkness' episode?”

Questions

Questions to carry into the episode.

Who are the hosts of this episode?

Andrea Canning and Josh Mankiewicz.

1
What is the title of the episode being discussed?

Out of the Darkness.

1
What exclusive content is shared in this podcast?

Josh Mankiewicz shares a podcast-exclusive clip from his interview with Bob's mother.

5

Experts

Voices named in the source.

Andrea Canning

Host

1

Josh Mankiewicz

Host

1

Sources and disclosure

Where this guide comes from.

Primary material

Talking Dateline: Out of the Darkness

Dateline NBC · Jul 8, 2026
How this guide was prepared

GenPod used an AI-assisted workflow to organize publisher-provided show notes into a listening guide. It is not independent reporting or fact-checking; verify important claims against the source episode.

Read our methodologyReport a correction
Source note

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company.

  1. Publisher show notes · Excerpt 1

    Andrea Canning sits down with Josh Mankiewicz to discuss his episode, “Out of the Darkness.” In 2016, Chacey Poynter called 911 in hysterics to report that her husband, Bob, a fire captain, had been fatally shot by a stranger on a Texas country road.

  2. Publisher show notes · Excerpt 2

    When police arrived at the scene, they found a frantic Chacey covered in her husband’s blood.

  3. Publisher show notes · Excerpt 3

    Investigators quickly surmised that her emotion and her story were far from genuine.

  4. Publisher show notes · Excerpt 4

    Andrea and Josh discuss the intensity of Chacey’s reaction, captured on police body cam, as well as the role of life insurance policies can play in murders.

  5. Publisher show notes · Excerpt 5

    Later, Josh shares a podcast-exclusive clip from his interview Bob’s mother.

  6. Publisher show notes · Excerpt 6

    Then, in a podcast first, Josh invites Andrea to partake in a special Talking Dateline challenge.

  7. Publisher show notes · Excerpt 7

    Have a question for Talking Dateline? DM your audio or video to @DatelineNBC on social or leave a voicemail at (212) 413-5252. Your question could be featured in an upcoming episode.

  8. Publisher show notes · Excerpt 8

    Listen to the full episode of “Out of the Darkness” here: https://swap.fm/l/outofthedarkness

  9. Publisher show notes · Excerpt 9

    Listen to Josh’s episode “Poison” here: https://swap.fm/l/poison

  10. Publisher show notes · Excerpt 10

    Watch Andrea fight off sweat bees here: https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=324321878130485

  11. Publisher show notes · Excerpt 11

    Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

Related listening guides

Choose what to hear next.