Standard DNA Testing Limitations
Standard forensic DNA tests scan about 20 fixed markers, which is usually sufficient to differentiate suspects, but this method often fails to distinguish between identical twins.
12Forensic Science
The Challenge of Identical Twins in Murder Investigations
When DNA evidence points to a set of identical twins, investigators face a unique challenge in determining which brother is guilty.
Listen to the source episode
13 Year Old Realizes His Twin Brother Is A Killer In The Middle Of Interrogation
Continue in GenPod
Turn this episode into your next question.
Ask naturally. GenPod can find a related episode—or make a focused explainer when the right one does not exist.Key takeaways
What to know before you press play.
Genetic Similarity of Twins
Identical twins share nearly identical DNA, differing by only about 8 letter typos out of 3 billion letters, making them genetically almost indistinguishable in standard tests.
3Advanced Testing Costs
Technology capable of distinguishing between identical twins is available at only a handful of labs and can cost hundreds of thousands or even millions of dollars.
4The Ohio Case
In Ohio, a woman was raped and murdered, and the DNA evidence pointed to a set of identical twins, leading to an investigation involving two 13-year-old boys.
567Ask GenPod next
Keep the question moving.
“How do investigators use non-DNA evidence to distinguish between twin suspects?”
“What are the legal implications when DNA evidence cannot definitively identify one twin over the other?”
“How common are criminal cases involving identical twins compared to the general population?”
Questions
Questions to carry into the episode.
Why is standard DNA testing insufficient for identical twins?
Standard tests scan about 20 fixed markers, which are often identical in twins, differing by only about 8 letter typos out of 3 billion letters.
123What is the cost of advanced DNA testing for twins?
The technology is available at a handful of labs and costs hundreds of thousands, even millions of dollars.
4Sources and disclosure
Where this guide comes from.
Full show notes available at RottenMangoPodcast.com
- Publisher show notes
A forensic DNA test usually scans about 20 fixed markers of DNA. It may take a few days but it’s enough to differentiate a suspect from the rest of the world with a near perfect level of certainty.
- Publisher show notes
Except for identical twins.
- Publisher show notes
It’s not a perfect analogy but think of DNA as a 3 billion letter book. Most people have about 20 chapters that are completely different. For identical twins, their entire book is identical except for about 8 typos. Not 8 different chapters, or sentences, not even 8 different words. 8 letter typos amongst 3 billion letters.
- Publisher show notes
The technology to find these is only available at a handful of labs and costs hundreds of thousands, even millions of dollars. Thankfully, identical twin crime is rare.
- Publisher show notes
Except for Ohio.
- Publisher show notes
A woman who lives alone is raped and murdered in her own home, and the DNA left at the scene traces back to a set of identical twins.
- Publisher show notes
Two 13 year old boys are the main suspects but which twin is innocent?
- Publisher show notes
And which twin is guilty?
- Publisher show notes
Full show notes available at RottenMangoPodcast.com
- Publisher show notes
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Related listening guides